Da li zaista trebamo da "cistimo" i defragmentujemo Registry?

4

Da li zaista trebamo da "cistimo" i defragmentujemo Registry?

offline
  • oblak  Male
  • Legendarni građanin
  • Glavni moderator foruma Mobilni telefoni
  • LEBE KISELI
  • Pridružio: 14 Feb 2005
  • Poruke: 6355

Reg bazu retko cistim iz prostog razloga sto aplikacije koje koristim "znam u prste" i retko sta probam na zivom sistemu sa takvim "ponasanjem" reg baza bude u pristojna dugo vremena.
Defragmentaciju vrsim samo prilikom kopiranja/premestanja vece kolicine fajlova i to samo na nesistemskom disku, sistem mi stoJi na SSD-u i o defragmentaciji i ne razmisljam. Za defragmentaciju koristim defragler poslednju portabilnu verziju.
Kada vec dodje do ciscenja baze koristim SAMO registry first aid poslednju azurnu verziju koju sam legalno kupio za 13$ na nekoj promociji pre par godina. Rfa je izuzetan alat veoma detaljan i mocan po "difoltu" prilagodjen prosecnom korisniku ali onima sa vise znanja daje ogromne mogucnosti...
Bekap sistema poveravam Acronis-u (image celog SSD diska) u kombinaciji sa recovery image-om (nemam odd na racunaru Mr. Green) podesen sistem vratim za 9-12 minuta...



Registruj se da bi učestvovao u diskusiji. Registrovanim korisnicima se NE prikazuju reklame unutar poruka.
offline
  • Pridružio: 19 Dec 2010
  • Poruke: 1106
  • Gde živiš: Beograd

Cistim Registry sa 2 minijaturna cistaca i to je to. Ne vise od jednom mesecno.



offline
  • Pridružio: 02 Feb 2008
  • Poruke: 14018
  • Gde živiš: Nish

Napisano: 15 Avg 2012 14:42

Jel ste culi za Mark Russinovich-a? U pitanju je lik koji radi od 2006 godine za Microsoft jer je MS kupio njegovu kompaniju Winternals Software, autor raznoraznih korisnih Windows alata, siroko priznat strucnjak 'unutrasnjosti' operativnog sistema Windows, narocito se interesuje za bezbednost i dizajn istog.

E sada taj lik je priupitan od strane jednog MS MVP-a (Bill Castner) da kaze nesto na temu registry cleaneri. Na linku ispod mozete procitati njegov odgovor i ne samo to.

Do I need a Registry Cleaner?
http://www.whatthetech.com/2007/11/25/do-i-need-a-registry-cleaner/


U svakom slucaju jos jednom je potvrdjeno da su registry cleaneri nepotreban software obicnom korisniku koji pojma nema kako registry baza radi i koji pojma nema sta to registry cleaner brise iz nje.


Takodje preporucujem citanje jos jednog zanimljivog, malo starijeg, teksta na ovu temu:

Registry Cleaners and System Tweaking Tools
http://miekiemoes.blogspot.com/2008/02/registry-cl.....ng_13.html



Culi ste za Bleeping Computer forum? U pitanju je nadaleko poznat forum nastao 2004 godine na kome clanovi mogu dobiti odgovore na razna pitanja vezano za racunar, izmedju ostalog i na temi bezbednost sistema (moguce je kod njih ocistiti malware kao kod nas u Ambulanti). Istaknut je u Microsoft Expert Zone zajednici, a preporucivan je vise puta i u PC World magazinu.
Na tom forumu takodje ne preporucuju koriscenje registry cleaner-a, a evo i zasto:
http://www.bleepingcomputer.com/forums/topic121827.....p__1571219

Dopuna: 12 Feb 2013 19:37

.






Registry Cleaner FAQ (By Tim Fisher, About.com Guide)
http://pcsupport.about.com/od/registry-cleaner/a/registry-cleaner-faq.htm

Citat:"Do I need to run a registry cleaner on a regular basis?"

No.

Citat:"My favorite registry cleaner says it fixes LOTS of problems in the registry. Is that not true?"

Most registry cleaners "do" a lot "stuff" in the registry, but I'd argue that most of that "doing" is fixing problems that simply don't exist.

Citat:"OK, maybe registry cleaning is overrated. But what's wrong with running one every day/week/month/year, just in case?"

A few reasons come to mind:
Letting an automated tool remove registry keys, especially ones not really causing problems, is risky.
It's a waste of your time.
It's a waste of your computer's resources

Actually, I'd go beyond overrated and say unnecessary. Why would you want to do any sort of maintenance that's unnecessary?



Do I need a Windows Registry cleaner? (odgovor dosta popularnog sajta za pomoc computerhope.com)
http://www.computerhope.com/issues/ch001077.htm

Citat:Registry cleaners are designed to help remove invalid references made in the Windows Registry pointing to a DLL, program, font, uninstalled program, or other system information that no longer exists on the computer. These references can be left behind when a program is not uninstalled properly, the uninstaller is poorly written, or the system has crashed in the past causing these invalid entries.

Although these utilities can make the Windows Registry clean, the overall potential benefits are greatly outweighed by the potential harm a they could cause. We suggest users do not install or use Windows Registry cleaners on their Windows computers.



Do you Still Believe in Registry Cleaners?
http://www.freemake.com/blog/do-you-still-believe-in-registry-cleaners/

Citat:Here are other factors why cleaners are no longer helpful:


1) Windows has a special utility which alerts you when there is little free space on your HDD, so that it influences the PC performance. The same utility cleans unnecessary files for you. So if you don’t receive such alerts, everything is OK with your PC storage.


2) Web browsers are getting faster and smarter with each update. Do you really believe that having cleared browser cache, you’ll make it run faster? No at all, it means that websites will load even longer, since you deleted the information about them from browser memory, so it will take more time to restore it.


3) It’s hard to figure out what information in Windows register is useful or useless. For example, by mistake you may delete some keys or components for a program which you removed from your system but decided to restore after some time. In this case you’ll get nothing but headache. There were even cases when users had to re-install Windows after cleaners work!


4) To really speed up a system, you must be a geek or an IT person at least, because only with the knowledge of Windows OS inside, you’ll be able to fine-tune it. The least you can do is to minimize Windows startup time, having disabled useless services which start together with the system.

Ko je trenutno na forumu
 

Ukupno su 824 korisnika na forumu :: 57 registrovanih, 12 sakrivenih i 755 gosta   ::   [ Administrator ] [ Supermoderator ] [ Moderator ] :: Detaljnije

Najviše korisnika na forumu ikad bilo je 3466 - dana 01 Jun 2021 17:07

Korisnici koji su trenutno na forumu:
Korisnici trenutno na forumu: AK - 230, Aleksandar Tomić, amaterSRB, Belac91, Bojan85, botta, Centauro, cilitis, darkstar101, Denaya, draganl, dragon986, Dukelander, dule10savic, Goran 0000, igorkuraj, Jahorina, jammedrudder, JimmyNapoli, Karla, Kenanjoz, Komentator, Kubovac, leonard, ljubacv, MB120mm, mercedesamg, Metanoja, Miki01, Milometer, Mixelotti, mrav pesadinac, Nemanja.M, nemkea71, nenad81, oldtimer, ozzy, Parker, procesor, repac, Romibrat, royst33, S2M, Sirius, slonic_tonic, solic, Srki94, Srle993, Steeeefan, stegonosa, su27, theNedjeljko, tmanda323, Tvrtko I, vladulns, voja64, VP6919